The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Olympic Committee wins gold for foot shooting

erm what? 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 14:48 GMT

Paris Hilton

How do the IOC have the right to make a takedown request on a video of a protest out side a Chinese Consulate in the US? I mean a little explanation would be great here....

Even Paris doesn't know why

brave? 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 14:52 GMT

You mean stupid yes?

Also even the Dalai Lama doesn't want a free Tibet, but instead a more autonomous Tibet. Only radicals and Westerners talk about a free Tibet.

The Power of the Internet 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 15:03 GMT

.

If they hadn't tried to ban it; you wouldn't have reported it; and, I & thousands others wouldn't have considered watching it.

Now that I have, I learn more about the Chinese atrocities towards the Tibetans.

@ AC 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 15:05 GMT

"A More Autonimous Tibet That Retains Territorial Integrity, Protection And Governance Of China Without Sacrificing It's Unique Traditions And Heritage NOW!"

Doesn't really work as a slogan, though. Does it?

The byline says it all 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 15:07 GMT

Thumb Down

"Free publicity for protest video"

Call me when you post something interesting.

Mark 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 15:08 GMT

(Written by Reg staff.)

hello,

It was a DMCA request - copyright essentially. I was unable to find the actual takedown notice, or contacts for someone likely to tell me - YouTube use an Irish postal address to receive notices in writing - but...

The video included use of the Olympic rings - the IOC keenly enforces its copyright claim to the rings

see here -

http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2002/02/50275

cheers

warning: Link contains drum and bass 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 15:23 GMT

Joke

..says John Oates, reaching for his slippers, pipe and 12" recording of Barbra Streisand Does the Classics...

@John Oates 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 15:47 GMT

Happy

Ok, cheers for that, I guess it makes some sort of sense to someone...

Misuse of the words "Brave" and "Hero" 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 15:48 GMT

Isnt it amazing - a journo gets arrested and "bravely" reports his plight to us - bit like that d*ckhead in "Die Hard 2" (who gets tazered for his troubles) - I do wish that the media and others would not use the words "Brave" or "Hero(ic)" when describing these people !!! Its a bit like describing somebody who has done nothing but train for the past X years who wins a medal and is described as a "sporting hero" - WTF.....makes my blood boil......

@Mark 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 15:51 GMT

Just for the record, the rings are a *trademark*, not a copyright. Thus the complaint gets filed with the PTO, not the copyright office. Furthermore, there's no time limit for a trademark.

@John: so no home videos then? 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 16:18 GMT

so I take that to mean that no one can have vacation videos of their trip to the Olympics?

if i can't take a picture of something on the street, then it shouldn't be on the street. restrain your trademarks from interfering with public rights in public places.

@ AC 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 16:21 GMT

Stop

You really think the Dalai Lama doesn't want a free Tibet? That given a choice between a free Tibet and an autonomous Tibet he'd chose the latter? It's called diplomacy. China will never enter negotiations with someone who wants a free Tibet, an autonomous Tibet is better than no concessions from the Chinese at all.

hmmmmmm 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 16:21 GMT

Joke

surely china would want the advertising seeing as all the "free tibet" t-shirts are made in china?

Free The iPhone / iPud /MacBook $50/mo Sweatshop Workers!! 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 16:24 GMT

Jobs Horns

Just remember the $50 per month - less living quarters and food charges - sweatshop workers, many under 15 years old, that make most ALL Apple products next time you plug in your iPud, admire your flaky iPhone and try or pray your MacBook boots up.

AppleTards = LibTard Hypocrites.

chinese communist pigs! 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 16:33 GMT

Pirate

china is an empire, not a country:

http://www.tibet.net/

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_people

the chinese people are not free, let alone these two groups living under the "communist" jackboot.

>:|

everybody needs to look after their rings 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 16:38 GMT

Unhappy

We in the Cult of the Sanctity of the Ringpieces wholeheartedly and warmly embrace the entirely democratic Inturnashnul Ooopslympics Commisariat and their robust defence of their rings

What an arse-clenchingly ridculous reason for suppression of expression

"the Dalai Lama doesn't want a free Tibet" 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 16:47 GMT

Stop

"even the Dalai Lama doesn't want a free Tibet, but instead a more autonomous Tibet. Only radicals and Westerners talk about a free Tibet."

Actually, yes he does. He simply knows that the Chinese politbureau would never allow it, so he's trying to get a compromise for his people, because it's better than nothing.

Only morons and posters for the Chinese government would think otherwise.

I can't speak for the Gyalpo Rinpoche, but... 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 17:49 GMT

The people of Tibet, strictly speaking, don't need political independence. But they would like to be free to practice their religion fully, to have ordinary civil liberties, and to have ownership of the land and resources of their historic homeland.

One of the ways to obtain these things would be for Tibet to become a fully sovereign nation, independent of China, and, given the horrors of the Cultural Revolution in the past, which took place under the same Communist institutions as govern China today, that would be the most solid and trustworthy way to obtain these things securely.

So, no matter how much the Dalai Lama may disclaim any desire to break Tibet away from China, as long as he continues to criticize China for how it governs Tibet now, instead of supporting China and dismissing things like the torture of dissidents as mere trivialities, of course he will be suspected of harboring such ambitions.

Witnessing recent events in Georgia, I'm just saddened that Russia and China still exist in their present form - instead of being non-nuclear nations under joint U.S. and British occupation, to be followed by a lengthy period of colonial tutelage.

@I can't speak for the Gyalpo Rinpoche, but... 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 18:20 GMT

IT Angle

"Witnessing recent events in Georgia, I'm just saddened that Russia and China still exist in their present form - instead of being non-nuclear nations under joint U.S. and British occupation, to be followed by a lengthy period of colonial tutelage."

WOT!? Like Burma & Uganda, for example? That sure showed them!

@Webster 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 18:31 GMT

Paris Hilton

Don't be a prat webster - do you seriously think Dell/HP/any other major pc manufacturer's factories are any different? You sound like a 4-year-old refusing to eat his greens. No-one cares about your irrational hatred, you're worse than the chinese, and they've been brainwashed by a corrupt totalitarian state. Open your eyes, you fool, and realise that all software (and all hardware) sucks, apple sucks no more than any other, and you sound like a lunatic every time you draw (literary) breath and post another predictable, biased, no-paris-angle rant.

You think the Chinese have it bad? 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 19:18 GMT

What about the Welsh? New coin designs are out featuring the Royal Arms (google royal mint new design), which is a heraldic emblem representing the four countries of Great Britain - so thats England, Scotland, Ireland and ... errr .. England again.

Death to the imperialistic English! Free Wales!

Superceded? 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 21:05 GMT

Yes, it's interesting how few people can spell superseded, isn't it?

@ Tom re Free Wales! 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 21:18 GMT

Gates Horns

Right on, brother, but what about Cornwall? What about Cornwall!?!?

evil billg because I'm sure he's at fault here as well, bastard.

We weren't always wrong... 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 21:32 GMT

"WOT!? Like Burma & Uganda, for example? That sure showed them!"

Or perhaps like Italy, Germany, and Japan -- you know, the ones we succeeded with.

@Tom 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 21:57 GMT

Joke

>Death to the imperialistic English! Free Wales!

Please DO free the rest of the UK from the sullen/sodden lump of rock known as Wales. Hell, even their prince doesnt live there !!

Bloody whingeing Celts, never stopped moaning since the Romans arrived and made them take baths and stop p*ssing in the streets .

The reason there aint no dragon there is obvious, the rest of the UK see Wales as one of thoses elderly aunt type of characters. You know the one, smells a little odd and says embarassing things to your friends. The one you would rather be elsewhere.

FREE WALES

@"@Tom" AC 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 22:29 GMT

Joke

It's more that the Irish are too drunk to draw dragons on flags, the Scots are too tightfisted to change theirs and the English... well, the English just don't care about anywhere outside London.

And for your information, Wales (and the rest of the UK) probably has some of the best street-pissing weather in the world, what with all the rain to wash it away with and all.

Their prince doesn't live there because he doesn't like being away from his mummy. The GM-and-computer-games hating eejit...

@b 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 23:23 GMT

Black Helicopters

"china is an empire, not a country:"

The same can be said for the U.S.A.

Do you have similar issues with the rank self interest and rabid imperialism that emanates from Washington DC, and has been nigh since WW1?

re: Wales 

Posted Thursday 14th August 2008 23:49 GMT

Coat

Is it even a country? I thought it was a bit of the country where the weather so bad that even the Romans didn't want to go there.

See: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1vh-wEXvdW8

Mines the one with the holiday home deeds in the pocket...

So, what's new? 

Posted Friday 15th August 2008 01:00 GMT

Thumb Down

The IOC is enabling the Chinese just like they enabled Hitler. So what else is new?

China 

Posted Friday 15th August 2008 06:45 GMT

Black Helicopters

You bloody hypocrite hippies. The only reason anyone is still shouting the stupid free tibet mantra is because its fashionable (celebrities do it). I'm South African, do you hear me whining about the concentration camps and the scorched earth policy of the Anglo-Boer war, or the corruption that is still taking place under UK (and other european) companies with the full knowledge of the government who is not willing to investigate it?

The UK, EU and US (therefore also UN) are all just as evil and corrupt if not more than China. It seems tat as long as the terrorists aren't targeting your country you call them freedom fighters. If I called the IRA freedom fighters I'd probably get arrested in the UK...

Where? 

Posted Friday 15th August 2008 07:55 GMT

Alert

http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/media/images/40143000/jpg/_40143516_wales_grab_203.jpg

@Censored 

Posted Friday 15th August 2008 08:00 GMT

"A More Autonimous Tibet That Retains Territorial Integrity, Protection And Governance Of China Without Sacrificing It's Unique Traditions And Heritage NOW!"

"Steady Progress And Limited Disobedience While Retaining Well-Formulated Good Manners!"

"Gently Push Over The Forces Of Repression!"

warning: Link contains drum and bass 

Posted Friday 15th August 2008 09:12 GMT

Unhappy

er - no it doesn't... how dare you get my hopes up - learn your music genres fools!

@ Tom 

Posted Friday 15th August 2008 09:12 GMT

Alert

"The winning designer is 26-year-old Matthew Dent, originally from Bangor who now lives and works in London as a graphic designer. "

That would be Bangor in Wales then would it?

@Dr Patrick J R Harkin 

Posted Friday 15th August 2008 09:59 GMT

The Great A'Tuin salutes you!

Thanks to the UK Government 

Posted Friday 15th August 2008 10:09 GMT

The law here makes the use of the word Olympic(s) extremely restricted along with gold, silver, bronze and 2012...

FREE WALES 

Posted Friday 15th August 2008 12:11 GMT

... can we free England instead? Sort of - we'll get the sensible parts of England together with the Welsh, Scots and Irish (if they'll have us) and build a bloody great wall around the M25 and leave the Government/London to themselves and leave the rest of us in peace?

Cantii Invicta!

AC as my family is from Kent - London is too damned close to them.

@Tom 

Posted Friday 15th August 2008 12:30 GMT

Happy

Great Britain is Scotland, England and Wales, you are thinking of the UK which does include Northern Ireland, I'm sure the Irish ( You said Ireland) would be surprised to hear they are part of either.

The Great A'Tuin salutes you! 

Posted Friday 15th August 2008 15:54 GMT

Happy

Thank you, Anonymous Coward! I don't suppose you'll be at the Convention next weekend?

Don’t Miss

Dollar101 uses for a former merchant banker

Comment Innovators who work out the best one will make a killing

The Year in Operating Systems: No battle of big ideas

Small change for 2009

Photography: Yes, you have rights

Comment Unless the police say you haven't

Enormous HP box spotted from space

Exclusive pics of Peterborough packaging pandemonium